If you’re a goods vehicle operator in the UK, you’ll either hold a restricted or a standard operator licence. Both allow you to legally run your transport business—but each comes with different responsibilities. So, when it comes to facing a Public Inquiry (PI), your licence type will influence not only what’s expected of you, but how you defend your case.
We’ll break down the differences between restricted and standard licences and explain how those differences affect your defence during a Public Inquiry. Whether you’re an experienced haulier or applying for your first operator licence, these insights are essential.
Understanding the Basics: Restricted vs Standard Licences
Before we dive into how each licence affects a PI defence, it’s important to understand the core differences between the two.
Restricted Operator Licence
A restricted operators licence is designed for businesses that only transport their own goods. This might include retailers, manufacturers, or construction firms using vehicles to move their own equipment or stock.
Key Features:
-
Cannot carry goods for hire or reward
-
No requirement to employ a professionally qualified transport manager
-
Still must maintain compliance with safety, maintenance, and record-keeping regulations
-
Often used by smaller firms with fewer vehicles
Standard Operator Licence
A standard licence allows you to carry goods for other people or businesses for payment.
Key Features:
-
Must employ a professionally qualified transport manager
-
Requires evidence of financial standing
-
Subject to greater scrutiny and higher compliance standards
-
Suitable for hauliers and logistics providers
Each licence is covered by the Operators Licence UK system and must meet the Traffic Commissioner’s requirements.
What Triggers a Public Inquiry?
A Public Inquiry is a formal hearing held by the Traffic Commissioner. It usually follows a compliance failure, complaint, or investigation. These issues often come up:
-
Poor maintenance records
-
Driver hours infringements
-
Financial standing concerns
-
Breach of licence terms
-
Inaccurate details on your operator licence application
-
Ineffective transport management
The type of licence you hold affects the Commissioner’s expectations—and the outcome of your PI.
How Your Licence Type Shapes the Traffic Commissioner’s Expectations
Expectations for Restricted Licence Holders
While restricted licence holders face slightly fewer regulatory demands, they are still expected to:
-
Keep vehicles roadworthy
-
Submit accurate applications
-
Follow drivers’ hours and working time rules
-
Keep clear maintenance and inspection records
Because restricted licence holders don’t need a qualified transport manager, the responsibility for compliance falls directly on the owner or business director. This can be a disadvantage during a PI if no one has been actively overseeing legal compliance.
Common Mistakes:
-
Believing restricted licences are ‘easier’ or more relaxed
-
Failing to keep track of tachograph data
-
Using vehicles outside the licence’s permitted purpose
Expectations for Standard Licence Holders
For standard licence holders, the bar is higher. The Traffic Commissioner will assess:
-
The effectiveness of the transport manager
-
Financial stability and cash reserves
-
Ongoing internal audits and record keeping
-
Whether your firm meets professional competence requirements
A poorly performing transport manager or weak compliance systems can result in serious penalties—even if your fleet is in decent condition.
How Your Defence Strategy Changes by Licence Type
Defending a Public Inquiry isn’t one-size-fits-all. Your defence will be shaped by the expectations of your licence category.
Defence Approach for Restricted Licence Holders
Because restricted operators manage compliance themselves, they need to show personal accountability and initiative.
Strong Defence Strategies Include:
-
Showing evidence of training or external consultancy help
-
Presenting organised records of maintenance and driver hours
-
Explaining how systems have improved since the breach
-
Demonstrating clear understanding of licence conditions
Restricted operators often benefit from hiring a transport consulting expert before the hearing to put proper systems in place.
Defence Approach for Standard Licence Holders
With a standard licence, the Commissioner expects a higher level of professionalism. A strong defence requires you to:
-
Prove your transport manager is qualified and engaged
-
Provide detailed audit trails for driver hours, maintenance, and tachographs
-
Show that financial standing requirements are being met
-
Present a compliance improvement plan that’s already in action
If the transport manager is part of the problem, you may need to replace them and demonstrate this change to the Commissioner.
Common PI Outcomes by Licence Type
Although all operators risk penalties, the outcome can vary depending on the licence.
Restricted Licence Outcomes
-
Licence suspension or curtailment
-
Warnings and undertakings (promises to improve systems)
-
Rarely revoked unless breaches are repeated or serious
-
May be required to undergo training or hire a consultant
Standard Licence Outcomes
-
Licence revocation or disqualification of transport manager
-
Severe curtailment (vehicle reductions)
-
Imposed conditions on operations
-
Financial audits and reporting obligations
Since standard licence holders are held to higher standards, failure often leads to stricter enforcement.
Real Example — Two Operators, Two Outcomes
Case A – Restricted Licence Holder
A landscaping company with a restricted licence was called to a PI for missed safety inspections. With our help, they introduced digital defect reporting and maintenance tracking. At the PI, the owner showed clear understanding of their role, and the Commissioner issued only a written warning.
Case B – Standard Licence Holder
A delivery firm with a standard licence failed to keep driver hour logs. The transport manager had no proof of regular checks. As a result, the licence was curtailed, and the manager was disqualified. Our team assisted in hiring a new manager and guided the firm through the reinstatement process.
The Cost of Getting It Wrong
Many operators focus only on the operators licence cost at the start. But failing to maintain compliance can cost much more in the long run.
Risks of Poor PI Defence:
-
Licence loss = business closure
-
Reapplication fees and delays
-
Higher insurance premiums
-
Damaged reputation with clients and regulators
Whether you hold a vehicle operators licence or a restricted operators licence, the risk is real. Don’t wait until it’s too late to seek support.
How Transport Consulting Helps Strengthen Your Case
At Blue Flag Transport Consulting, we help operators build solid PI defence cases by:
-
Reviewing current compliance status
-
Auditing internal systems and records
-
Helping replace or train transport managers
-
Preparing for hearings with professional representation
-
Managing new operator licence applications and renewals
We understand the differences between licence types and tailor our support accordingly.
📞 Call to Action
Need help defending your operator licence at a Public Inquiry? Whether you hold a restricted operators licence or a standard one, Blue Flag Transport Consulting has the experience and knowledge to help you succeed.
We’ll guide you through every step—from compliance checks to full restoration of your licence. Contact us today and take control of your future in the UK transport industry